Skip to content

Job offers

How to compare two job offers

Updated 7 min read

The short answer

Decide what matters to you before you look closely at the offers, and give each thing an importance from 1 to 5. Then compare the offers one factor at a time, price the pay over two years rather than one, and find the single unknown that could flip your answer. Get that answer before you accept.

Start with what matters to you, not with the offers

Most people compare job offers by staring at both and waiting for a feeling. The trouble is that the most exciting detail (a bigger title, a famous name, a round salary number) quietly takes over, and the things that will shape your days get less attention than they deserve.

Turn it around. Before you compare anything, write down the four to six things that matter most to you in your next job, and give each one an importance from 1 (nice to have) to 5 (critical). Common ones:

  • Pay and benefits: salary, bonus, equity, retirement match, health cover and time off.
  • Growth and learning: what you'll be able to do in two years that you can't do now.
  • Manager and team: the people you'll spend most of your working hours with.
  • Work-life balance: hours, on-call, flexibility, and remote or office days.
  • Stability: the company's funding, revenue trend and recent layoffs.
  • The work itself: whether you'd still find it interesting in month six.

Setting importance first stops you from adjusting your priorities to fit the offer you already like. If you find yourself wanting to change a number after you see the result, that's useful too: something matters more to you than you admitted.

Compare total pay over two years, not salary over one

Salary is the easiest number to compare and often not the most important one. Put every part of the package side by side and look at two years, so one-off payments and vesting schedules show up fairly.

What to include when you compare pay
ItemWhat to check
Base salaryThe number itself, and when the next pay review happens.
BonusThe target, and how much of the target was actually paid out last year.
EquityThe vesting schedule, any cliff, and whether you could ever sell it. Treat private-company equity as a maybe, not as cash.
Signing bonusWhether you would have to pay it back if you left within a year or two.
Retirement matchThe match percentage, and how long until it is yours to keep.
Health coverWhat you would pay in premiums and deductibles, especially with dependents.
Time offPaid days off, parental leave, and whether people actually take them.
CommuteTravel costs and hours per week. Time spent commuting is unpaid work.

A higher salary can easily be canceled out by a smaller bonus that is actually paid, worse health cover or two extra hours of commuting a day. If one offer still pays clearly more after all this, good: now you know exactly what that money is competing against.

Score the offers one factor at a time

Now go factor by factor and ask one question: which offer is better here, and by how much? A bit better, much better or about the same is enough. You don't need false precision.

Weigh each answer by how much that factor matters to you and add it all up. That is a weighted decision matrix, and it does something a pros and cons list cannot: it shows you the real trade-off. For example:

Example: a startup offer and a bank offer

The bank pays a bit more, has better balance and is much more stable. The startup is much better for growth. With growth at 4 out of 5, it is close, with the bank just ahead. The tipping point: if growth mattered 5 out of 5 instead of 4, the startup would come out ahead. And the manager is still unknown for both, which could decide it either way.

That last part is the most useful thing a comparison can tell you. If a one-point change in importance flips the result, the decision really is close, and your energy is better spent on the questions below than on another spreadsheet.

Find the unknown that could decide it

When two offers are close, the deciding factor is often something you don't know yet, and the manager is the most common one. Before you accept, try to answer the questions that could change your result:

  • Manager and team: ask to speak with someone on the team, and notice how the manager talks about mistakes and about the last person who left.
  • Growth: ask what the last person in this role went on to do, and what you would learn in your first year.
  • Balance: ask what a normal week looks like, and when people actually log off.
  • Stability: look up recent funding, layoffs and revenue trends, and ask how the team's budget has changed this year.
  • The role: ask for a rough outline of your first 90 days, so you know the job matches the description.

These are normal questions at the offer stage. Good employers expect them, and how they answer is part of the answer.

Use one offer to improve the other, honestly

If you prefer one offer but the other pays more, you can usually ask your preferred company to close part of the gap. Keep it simple and true:

  1. Tell them they're your first choice, if they are. It makes them want to solve the problem.
  2. Say you have another offer and name the specific gap, such as base salary or a signing bonus. Share numbers only if you're comfortable, and never invent or inflate an offer.
  3. Ask for one or two specific changes rather than a vague "can you do better?".
  4. Get any change in writing before you accept.

If they can't move on salary, there may be room on a signing bonus, start date, title, remote days or an earlier pay review. The paid action plan includes the exact call script and email for this.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Comparing salary only. Total pay over two years and the cost of the commute often tell a different story.
  • Letting one exciting detail decide. A famous name or a bigger title can crowd out everything else in your head, even when it matters less to you than the people you would work with.
  • Deciding at the deadline. Score the offers as soon as you have both, so the last days go into getting answers, not panicking.
  • Ignoring the manager. A bigger salary doesn't fix a bad manager.
  • Counting unvested or private equity as cash. It might be worth a lot, or nothing.
  • Assuming you can't ask for more. A polite, specific request rarely costs anyone an offer.

Before you sign

Once you've chosen, get the final offer in writing and check the title, level, start date, pay, bonus terms, equity details, remote policy and any non-compete or repayment clauses. If you need a few more days, ask politely and say which day you'll reply; most employers would rather wait than lose a candidate they want. Then decline the other offer warmly. You may want to work with those people one day.

Common questions

What is the most important factor when choosing between two job offers?

It depends on what matters most to you right now, which is why it helps to set your own importance for each factor before comparing. That said, the manager and the day-to-day work shape your experience far more than a small pay difference, so don't let a modest salary gap decide on its own.

Should I take the job offer with the higher salary?

Take it if it still comes out ahead once you compare total pay over two years and weigh what else matters to you. If pay is your top priority right now, it may well be the right choice. If it's close, find the factor that would tip it and get that answer first.

How long can I take to decide on a job offer?

A few days to a week is common, and asking questions during that time is normal. If you need longer, ask politely and say which day you'll reply. Most employers would rather wait a little than lose a candidate they want.

Is it okay to tell a company I have another offer?

Yes, as long as it's true. Mentioning a real competing offer is a normal part of negotiating. Don't invent offers or inflate numbers: it can backfire if they ask for details, and it isn't fair to them.

Is there a free tool to compare job offers?

Yes. Clearfork's free decision tool walks you through comparing two offers factor by factor, weighs them by what matters to you, and shows the tipping point and the unknown that could decide it. It runs in your browser and needs no signup.